Welcome to TRF. Sorry it has be under such unhappy circumstances, but at least you are unharmed. As Atomic said, no watch is worth the risk of getting shot by some a$$hole.
But on to happier things. We're glad to have you here as part of the TRF family. Stick around and enjoy the fun.
And as for your question, there's only one answer as far as I am concerned. Another black/black GMT. But then as anyone around here can tell you, that is my favorite watch by far. Of all my watches, the all black gets the most wear time. So go for it and replace the black GMT. You will not be sorry.