Trade opinions please?

[kwingy]

Guys would you trade a PepsiC (got at retail) for a green dial 118238?

I expect to pay some cash on top but not sure of the total yet.

Opinions welcome.

TIA.

[travisb]

Do whatever makes you happy and comfortable with.
Personally, I prefer the BLRO and would not trade it towards a DD.

[rmlovett1]

Me personally….would depend on what else I had in my collection. I’d also opt for 40mm vs 36

[GGGMT]

No on 36 dd. But you do you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[kwingy]

Originally Posted by rmlovett1

Me personally….would depend on what else I had in my collection. I’d also opt for 40mm vs 36

From a SS perspective - I have watches like a Daytona 116520 and a Tiffany OP.

Thanks for opinions so far.

[Harry-57]

If it works for you, it works. I wouldn't, but I'm not you.

[1William]

I like both watches and would see if I could do a fair deal. If the numbers are right then I would make a decision. For me, probably not but if that is what you want then go for it.

[SteveY]

I’m more inclined to keep the PepsiC but trade 116520.

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by travisb

Do whatever makes you happy and comfortable with.
Personally, I prefer the BLRO and would not trade it towards a DD.

[joli160]

For me the 36 DD is the ultimate Rolex. I would not think twice

[kwingy]

Originally Posted by SteveY

I’m more inclined to keep the PepsiC but trade 116520.

Same but unfortunately the 116520 is really tanking at the moment lol. I am loathed to sell it cheaply having paid a resale price on it quite high last year.

[forg]

That’s a trade I wouldn’t make…… but that’s just me

[kwingy]

Originally Posted by joli160

For me the 36 DD is the ultimate Rolex. I would not think twice

I had the 18238 a few years ago and I sold it for a decent price. Lusting after one again especially this time in the green dial and solid links

[Robb]

No. I would not make that trade.

[Hardtimes]

I would for sure!!

[Beto737]

Whatever makes you happy and speaks to you. For me however, I wouldn’t make that trade..

[EvelynWaugh]

That would depend on the year and the condition of the green dial 118238 and how complete it is as a set.

[Easy E]

Trade the Daytona

[jb335]

Sorry, but which dial DD 36? The new green ombre with Roman’s or the existing ombré with diamonds?


Edit: woops, I see you wrote 118, I was thinking 128. So I know it’s not a new ombré. Please dont pull my Rolex card.

Still not sure which green dial was out for the 118 series though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[piratfisk]

Normally yes, I'd take a DD36 over a BLRO. I do not, however, think the YG/green combo looks great. It's very showy, which is not my style. It may be yours, however.

[EvelynWaugh]

Originally Posted by jb335

Sorry, but which dial DD 36? The new green ombre with Roman’s or the existing ombré with diamonds?


Edit: woops, I see you wrote 118, I was thinking 128. So I know it’s not a new ombré. Please dont pull my Rolex card.

Still not sure which green dial was out for the 118 series though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

.

[Kiddodoc]

I am not a fan of the 36 mm DD but it works well with some with smaller wrists. The green dial is beautiful but not my cup of tea. I would rather ditch the Daytona than the Pepsi as I prefer the newer Daytona's with ceramic bezels as the SS bezel is a scratch magnet. Good luck on your decision.

[KenRose]

Originally Posted by EvelynWaugh

.

I love that watch!

[JenaG]

I would definitely do that trade, if it was 1976!!!

[KatGirl]

Originally Posted by brandrea

Me, too!

Kat


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Henrimontgomery]

Originally Posted by kwingy

Same but unfortunately the 116520 is really tanking at the moment lol. I am loathed to sell it cheaply having paid a resale price on it quite high last year.

How do you mean the 116520 is tanking? Price sit around 20-30k still depending of NOS-ness.

[kane818]

I would rather keep the pepsi

I assume since you're contemplating the trade that maybe you're getting tired of it though, in which case go for the trade!

[StellarisCollection]

I would keep the Pepsi! A timeless piece in my books.

[Cru Jones]

36 DD in YG is amazing. I would go for it, especially with your other SS watches. Personally, I would go for one of the new ‘24 dials though.

[881]

No even without knowing the full trade conditions