Beacon Hill Jewelers holding my watch hostage

[andromeda160]

Long story short I sold a watch on here, ad the buyer filed a chargeback through his CC company. The original payment was through PayPal. Despite evidence supporting me, the CC company refunded him. When I asked him to send me my watch back he sent a rude message stating he would do me no favors and I could have fedex come pickup package the watch and ship it ect. But he wouldn't ship it out. Furthermore he said it would be another month before I could do so because he hasn't recieved a letter from his CC company stating its been settled despite PayPal telling me it's done and can't be reversed. He won't respond to messages and I'm running out of ideas on what to do. He has a B&M business which is why I find it odd he would steal my $950 watch. What recourse do I have to take? He's in a different state then me as well if that makes a difference.